Why Huntington Is Full of It

If you haven’t already, please check out my latest column for The Week, an economium to the peaceable multicultural paradise that is Toronto.

Update: Some of you are asking for this, which you can find here

Advertisements

24 thoughts on “Why Huntington Is Full of It

  1. Toronto really is a wonderful city.But–In my few days there, not once did I hand cash to a white person in a commercial transaction. Not in any retail store, not in any restaurant, not at the hotel. In a city that's more white than not, I found that odd, and a little disturbing. My hometown, definitely not paradise, struggles with issues of race and caste, and yet here the divisions are much less stark. You never really make the comparison you want to make. What's the percentage of foreign born in Canada, and what's the percentage in the US? (Foreign-born residents are a majority in Miami-Dade–is it a paradise like Toronto?)Finally, it should at least be mentioned that the speaker's corner in Toronto comes with an asterix.

  2. Of that 47% that is non-Canada born, how many were born in the UK, Australia, New Zealand, rest of Europe, and the US? I could not find that breakdown.What I did find is that of the “visible minorities”, 70% were of Asian ancestry. The vast majority from India and China.Is there a comparable city in the US with a similar demographic breakdown to compare against?You quote the murder rate being low, is the property crime rate, assaults, etc. crime rate just as low?

  3. “Is there a comparable city in the US with a similar demographic breakdown to compare against?”Hmm. Maybe San Francisco?

  4. The article reeks of Cato (can't evenhandedly acknowledge drawbacks of libertarian policy planks) Institute bait and switch, except the bit about cultural decay not being so worrying with the Canadian immigrant mix. We don't get a mention of the fact that a much higher fraction of Canadian immigrants are selected through a point system (favoring those who speak English or French, have significant educational credentials, etc) to get immigrants who will assimilate relatively well. You also completely ignore the issue of the ancestry of the Canadian immigration flows, which are disproportionately Chinese and upper-middle class Indian.Black Canadians underperform in school to an extent comparable to blacks in the U.S., show elevating rates of crime and substance abuse, and a hugely disproportionate share of murders in Toronto (every year there is a parade called Caribana, regularly accompanied by gun murders by Canadians of African descent), which doesn't push the city's overall murder rate too high because of the relatively limited African population and the low crime rates among other groups.There was recent hand-wringing in the national papers here about studies showing that the children of immigrants from different countries and of different racial backgrounds regress to different means: when you compare Chinese and black immigrants of equal income and education, the children of the Chinese earn more while the black children earn less than their parents.All Canada tells you is what everyone already knows: skilled Asian immigrants integrate well. So take lots more of them, like Canada, but don't try to trick your readership.

  5. So you're saying that you accept the idea that liberal democratic institutions can survive a huge influx of outsiders who do not share the culture that created those institutions — as long as they're the right outsiders? You admit that Chinese and Indian culture is not much like Anglo-Protestant culture, right? So you agree that Toronto proves Huntington wrong?

  6. Yes, I agreed in my first sentence: “except the bit about cultural decay not being so worrying with the Canadian immigrant mix.” I don't care if we all speak English or Mandarin or Hindi, and I don't think Chinese immigrants bring too much in the way of illiberal values (absolutely not for HK, not too worryingly for PRC migrants). But I don't want the engines of economic (and critically scientific and technological) growth in advanced countries to be screwed up by outright open borders/unconditional migration rights (I liked your nod to guest workers).But you chose to talk about the low crime rates, quality of life, etc, without a disclosure of the role of immigrant mix.

  7. San Fran or Seattle, magnets for Asian immigration, would be the closet you could come, I think. Yes. Toronto's crime rate is astonishingly low on every metric. In fact, it is safer than most other Canadian cities, such Saskatoon and Winnipeg, all with smaller populations of immigrants, which suggests the possibility that Toronto's immigrants actually bring down the crime rate.

  8. I think you're going to have to fight through some significant selection bias here, Will. I'd like to see the United States issue more visas to skilled workers. But there is a huge difference between people applying for citizenship with Canada and making it through their screening process, and day laborers hopping the border from Mexico. Which group do you think will be more compliant with liberal democractic institutions?By logical extension of your argument, shouldn't we believe the neocons when they say that, if we only try hard enough, we can export liberal democratic institutions and fix the world?

  9. One counterexample: Israel's new (Russian) crypto-Fascist Foreign Minister, Lieberman, is backing Putinesque policies that appeal to recent Russian immigrants.

  10. Pingback: Topics about Toronto » Blog Archive » Why Huntington Is Full of It

  11. Many xenophobes in Europe are asking for more Asian immigrants and less Muslims. If we want to destroy xenophobia, we have to focus on Muslims, African refugees and low-skilled Mexicans. Asians, highly educated immigrants and secular Muslims are already accepted by almost everyone.

  12. I'd say there're a lot of pieces missing from your argument. As other commenters have pointed out, we'd first need to know the breakdown of “foreign-born” residents in Toronto. Huntington's objections are to specific classes of immigrants, and you would therefore have to show that Toronto was accepting those classes, not merely that they have a lot of immigrants. Since Huntington's argument is based on cultural rot more than on immigration anyway, you would probably also need to say something about the class and race of native-born Torontonians as well. More importantly, you would need to supply some comparative statistics showing (rather than merely speculating, as in your comment above) that Toronto's relatively low crime rate is not disproportionately accounted for by immigrants. You would probably also need to explain why some cities like Tokyo, which are considerably less diverse than Toronto, are also safer (i.e. single-point comparisons are usually not persuasive). Where I think your argument succeeds is in refuting the idea that immigration/cultural dillution alone can account for rises in crime. Clearly crime and immigration are not directly correlated in the way that Huntington suggests. But there is still a quite a distance between having proved that and showing that immigration is not one of the (or even the primary) contributing factors to a city's crime rate. It can still be the case that, controlling for all other variables, reducing immigration and/or screening immigrants for factors which suggest they can and will easily assimilate into Anglo-Saxon culture helps control crime.My concern here is not to argue against immigration, incidentally. I agree with your “guest-worker programs, not walls” aside. It's more that I don't think you're doing “our side” any favors with this kind of argumentation. Toronto's single data point based on statistics gained from a single year – and with little or no characterization of the context – is not convincing.

  13. Thank you very much for posting the country of birth information for the immigrants in Canada. I was quite surprised that the number of folks from the UK, Australia, US, and rest of Europe was that low.Again on the topic of the crime rate. Is there a non-US born (legal or illegal) immigrant subset more prevalent in the US that have a higher crime rate per capita that is NOT a prevalent immigrant subset in Canada?Are the crime rates for the Chinese, Indian, Pakistani, etc immigrants in Canada comparable to US figures for the same immigrant groups? If the crime rates across the two countries for the same immigrant groups are comparable, then maybe it has to do with something in the culture of the immigrant groups. If Canada is much lower, then maybe there is something in the water up north??Finally, according to Wikipedia, the illegal immigrant population is less than 1% (120K / 33M). I think that has to be a factor.

  14. Relatedly, there's a lot of progress to be made on openness to those desirable immigrant groups: Canada is a leader (in its per capita immigration intake) on that front. The U.S. H1-B cap and the foolish policy of sending those H1-B skilled workers home after 3 or 6 years comes to mind as a contrast. Consider an immigration bill that tightened border enforcement (including popular measures like physical border walls) and employer sanctions to discourage illegal immigrants while allowing unlimited skilled immigration: such a bill would easily pass and have global welfare benefits far exceeding the status quo.

  15. “…such a bill would easily pass…”lol! If so, it would have already passed.As soon as the unions get on board, it would easily pass, and as soon as the unions get on board it would be a crappy bill.

  16. I was surprised to see no bump in the percentage of immigrants from the US for 2006 (the first year in the graphic after 2004). Gee, my reading of the NYT suggested they should've seen at least… oh say 1/2 million from that city alone after the '04 election.

  17. Yeah a simple immigration bill that tightened border enforcement while allowing unlimited skilled immigration.. its true.. such a bill would easily pass and have global welfare benefits far exceeding the status quo…hotel rewards free cash cards

  18. cardy ugg boots On sale,Find newest Ugg Collection there. cardy uggs Special sale,Order now,Save 38% immediately cardy uggs boots This season hit the store,Only $99Would you like a pair of classic short ugg home,make this winter warm,let you feet keep comfort every day. Newest classic short uggs is in stock now,Save more off,Win lucky coupon code.women's bailey button UGG this season hottest Short style UGG Boots,you should never miss it. Bailey Button UGGs keep your feet amazing comfort,Special sale time is limited this week,Order nowUGGs Bailey Button Boots can't find?You can go our shop,Will save more 25%.UGG Bailey Button Sale Come in stock,win more discount now.Chestnut Bailey Button Boot this season hottest Ugg boots,every one is talk about that,Take them home now. bailey button leopard Ugg boots let the fashion on your feet now,A pair of this will give you all.<H3>Leopard Uggs New version of Ugg Bailey Button hit the store</H3><H3>UGG Australia Highkoo 2009-2010 this winter a new rasie trendy along with bailey button button.</H3><H3>UGG Women's Highkoo Will the best gift for christmas,for your girlfriend,your family member</H3><H3 jQuery1250860456437=”26″>UGG Grey Women's Highkoo keep rising,don's miss this opportunity to get them home with cheapest price you never imagin.</H3><H3> </H3><H3> </H3>   

Comments are closed.